iMagine Transformation

Insights

The Thinking Organisation Series, part 5 of 7

We Can't Survey Our Way Out of Dismissive Behaviour

Every year, the survey goes out. Every year, the scores come back. Every year, the workshops run, the action plans get built, and the tidy narrative gets presented to leadership (I've sat in plenty of these rooms myself). And then, almost without exception, everyone goes right back to doing the very thing the scores were complaining about. There's a word for that.

Employee engagement has become one of corporate life's more elaborately produced theatre performances.

The survey goes out. Dashboards arrive. Heatmaps get discussed with extraordinary seriousness by people who will leave the meeting and immediately go and do the very thing the heatmap is complaining about. Action plans get produced, circulated, and presented to the right governance structure. And then, almost without exception, everyone returns to the behaviours that made the scores so predictable in the first place.

Survey. Workshop. Narrative. Repeat.

It puts out all the energy of good intentions (and frankly, has about as much impact).

To be fair to the process itself: Engagement surveys, used well, genuinely do work. A well-designed survey with real leader involvement and visible follow-through moves both the scores and the underlying behaviour. The research backs that up. The problem isn't the instrument. It's what gets done with it, which is typically watching the metric while leaving the behaviour it's measuring completely intact. You end up measuring the residue of habits nobody's willing to examine. Which is why the whole cycle feels so familiar. So circular. And, if you've sat through enough of these rooms, demoralising.

What almost nobody says out loud is that people don't feel engaged because you asked them once a year how they're feeling. They feel engaged when, in the moments that actually matter, they experience that they matter. And that has nothing to do with the survey cycle. It gets decided in everyday behaviour:

Who gets interrupted. Who gets genuinely heard. Who gets invited in, and who gets diplomatically managed. Who gets thanked for raising a difficult truth and then sidelined for doing it. Who learns that challenge is welcome right up until the moment it becomes mildly inconvenient for someone senior.

The organisation builds those patterns. It sustains them. Then it commissions a survey to find out why everyone seems so disengaged.

Meanwhile, the people in question are making entirely rational decisions. They hold back. They stay safe. They contribute considerably less than they're capable of, not because they lack commitment, but because they're responding intelligently to the environment that actually exists, rather than the one the values poster describes.

Gallup's research consistently identifies manager behaviour as the single largest driver of disengagement, ahead of pay, ahead of structure, ahead of almost everything else leadership teams spend their time debating.

You just can't survey your way out of dismissive behaviour. A pity, really. It would save a lot of workshops.

Next: Why making anonymity the permanent default for employee voice creates a culture that's very good at collecting sentiment and rather less good at building honest conversation.

First published on LinkedIn.

If this describes something in your organisation, that’s a good place to start a conversation.