iMagine Transformation

Insights

The Thinking Organisation Series, part 4 of 7

Removing the Leader Is Not the Answer

One of the stranger habits in organisational life is removing leaders from the conversation and calling the result psychological safety. I understand the instinct. But I think it's worth asking what that habit actually builds, underneath the good intentions.

One of the more damaging habits I keep encountering in organisational life is removing leaders from the conversation and calling the result psychological safety.

I understand the instinct. In low-trust environments, where power has been abused and people have learned that honesty carries unpleasant consequences, creating a protected space can be a necessary and genuinely compassionate starting point. Sometimes it's the only place you can begin.

But when leader exclusion becomes the default design, we’ve created a different problem entirely. One that teaches people something rather damaging: That honesty is only safe once power has left the building. The distinction matters. A leader-free session can be a legitimate starting point in a genuinely low-trust environment. The problem is when it stops being a starting point and becomes the permanent architecture, the unquestioned way things are done long after the original rationale resolved itself.

So yes, there are environments where anonymity isn't just reasonable, it's necessary. Where the risk of retaliation is real and people need some assurance of protection before they can speak at all. The research backs this up. A staged approach (surfacing themes privately first, then working toward leader-inclusive conversation) can be sound, thoughtful practice. I've used it myself.

I'm also aware that even the most inclusive leader can't fully close the power gap for everyone in the room, and that some structural inequities need structural responses, not just better individual behaviour. Those are real and important caveats.

My concern is when this becomes the expected approach with no plan to ever graduate from it into genuine candour in open conversation. That's not how you build a high-trust culture. That's how you build an elaborate workaround and convince yourself it’s the real thing.

There's something else this permanent design costs us. The leader who walks back into a room where a conversation happened without them isn't returning to neutral territory. They know something was said. They don't know what. They can sense the shape of it in the silence. That's not a condition that builds openness, curiosity, or the kind of vulnerable leadership that actually earns trust. What it produces is guardedness, and guarded leaders tend to become defensive leaders (which conveniently validates the very distrust that started the whole cycle).

Psychological safety isn't a gift leaders hand down to teams. It's a condition the whole system either has or doesn't. Leaders need it just as much, to think clearly under pressure, to hear difficult things without defending, to take real risks in full view of the people they lead. Take them out of the conversation and you haven't just withheld information from them. You've made it harder for them to be exactly what everyone most needs them to be.

The goal was never a parallel system where people only speak once the senior people have left the room. The goal is a culture where truth can be spoken, and heard, in the room, with leaders present and actually listening. If people can only be candid when their leaders aren't there, you haven't built psychological safety. You've institutionalised the distrust and given it a process.

The research backs this too. Nembhard and Edmondson found that when leaders were experienced as genuinely inclusive (actively welcoming others' input, staying curious rather than defensive, handling difficult information with maturity rather than ego) psychological safety improved and the status gap between senior and junior people narrowed significantly. The answer to hierarchy was never leader disappearance. It's leader behaviour that actually makes candour possible.

That's considerably harder work than leaving the room. Which is probably why it matters so much more.

Next: Why the engagement survey cycle has become one of corporate life's more elaborately produced theatre performances, and what to do instead.

First published on LinkedIn.

If this describes something in your organisation, that’s a good place to start a conversation.