Performance Punishment
We talk a lot about productivity.
How can we do more? How can we do it better? How can we do it faster?
Fair questions, but I think that there’s another question we should be asking: “What have we taught people happens when they become really good at their work?”
Because many of us know how to do more, to a higher standard, in less time than we used to. And what happens then?
- Do we get some of that time back?
- Does the workload reduce?
- Does the reward increase?
Or does the organisation figure out that we can now do considerably more than before?
Not necessarily because anyone is being exploitative. It just seems to be something that happens. Productivity demands are rising. The high performer does more in less time, and so the organisation concludes that they have capacity to take on even more. Expectations adjust. The exceptional becomes the new normal.
And so we learn quickly that being efficient can result in more work being piled on. That being dependable can mean becoming the person who gets the difficult things. That finding a faster way through a process can mean being given the next process too.
This is where the rather uncomfortable idea of performance punishment comes in.
Could some of the things we complain about as “resistance to change” actually be people responding rationally to the consequences they have experienced before?
- Why change the process if doing so simply creates capacity for another six tasks?
- Why finish early if the reward for finishing early is being tasked with something else?
- Why demonstrate that the work can be done in four hours when the inevitable conclusion might be that it should now take three?
I've been thinking about this on and off for a few weeks now, wondering why so many organisational challenges seem to have fairly obvious solutions and yet, never get resolved. And it occurred to me that sometimes the seemingly pointless meeting, the unnecessary process, the duplicated administration, even the slightly ridiculous bit of organisational faff may be serving an entirely different function than what we think:
Perhaps it is creating breathing space. Not productive breathing space, admittedly. But space to breathe nonetheless, because if every efficiency gain is immediately converted into additional output, there's very little in it for the person doing the work.
We have just increased the rate at which we're extracting it from them.
If that is their lived experience, no wonder nothing changes.
Just as importantly, productivity is not the only thing that suffers.
There is a substantial body of occupational-health research linking high job demands, job strain and effort-reward imbalance with poorer health outcomes. A major meta-analysis found that effort-reward imbalance and job strain were associated with increased risk of sickness absence for diagnosed mental disorders. (source).
Research has also linked psychosocial stress at work, including effort-reward imbalance, with cardiovascular disease. And research on overcommitment (the tendency to respond to work demands with excessive effort and difficulty switching off) correlates physiological stress responses with elevated blood pressure.
I think what strikes me most is what happens when highly driven, conscientious people repeatedly respond to increasing demands by stretching their capacity further and further, while the system keeps expecting more and more.
Eventually, something’s got to give.
Sometimes it is energy, sometimes engagement. Sometimes it's judgement and quality. And sometimes it's the wellbeing of our people.
That's pretty ironic from the organisation’s perspective.
Burnout is associated with absenteeism and presenteeism, and with poorer job performance. We also know from a substantial body of research that work engagement is positively associated with performance and negatively associated with absenteeism. A 2022 meta-analysis covering 179 unique correlations and more than 139,000 people found exactly that. (source).
So the commercial consequence of repeatedly rewarding great performance with increasing demand can turn out very differently from the one we intended, i.e. We may think we are getting more, when in actual fact, we're depleting (and potentially exhausting) the very capacity we depend upon.
This is not a problem unique to one organisation, one industry or one country. It is a feature that can emerge in almost any system where increasing capacity is treated as an invitation to increase demand.
Realistically we can't redesign the global world of work from a single team. But certainly we can all do well to take a closer look at what's happening directly around us.
We can notice what happens in our team when someone makes something faster, better or easier.
- Do we give some of that capacity back?
- Do we take something else off the list?
- Do we create room for thinking, learning, recovery and creativity?
Or do we simply move the goalposts?
This is the question I really think we should be considering: "If our people knew they could do more, better, in less time - and wouldn’t be punished for it - what would they do differently?"
And perhaps the more useful question after that is: "What would we need to change in our team, to make that a safe thing to discover?"
First published on LinkedIn.