iMagine Transformation

Insights

The Thinking Organisation Series, part 2 of 7

Nobody Stops Speaking Up All at Once

Nobody stops speaking up all at once. That would be too obvious to catch and far too easy to fix. What actually happens is slower, harder to spot, and considerably more expensive (and most leaders are doing it without the faintest idea).

Nobody stops speaking up all at once. That would be too obvious. Too easy to spot and far too easy to fix.

In most organisations, people are trained out of candour so gradually that nobody notices it happening, including, rather importantly, the people doing the training. It's rarely one dramatic moment, although when it is, it tends to become organisational folklore: That thing that happened to someone once in a meeting, retold for years, making everyone flinch slightly each time the story comes up.

More often, the training happens in a hundred small moments that look insignificant in isolation and add up to something else entirely. The interruption halfway through a sentence. The leader who puts his own idea on the table before inviting anyone else's. The one who asks for honest feedback and starts rebutting before the point has fully landed. The visible impatience when someone takes too long to get there. The glance at the phone. The habit of filling every pause, because somewhere between 2015 and now, silence got reclassified as a productivity risk.

These micro-signals barely register for the person sending them. To the person receiving them, they're data: Reliable, repeated, carefully filed-away evidence of what actually happens when you put your neck out, and whether it was worth it.

Psychological safety doesn't live in the values statement. It isn't in the all-hands speech, or the slide that says “we welcome honest conversations.” It lives entirely in the micro-behaviours: Whether you feel genuinely listened to, whether there's real equality in whose voice gets space and whose gets managed, and whether a contribution is actually appreciated rather than simply noted (there's a real difference, and you can always tell which one you're getting).

More often though, the political tightrope just feels safer to avoid altogether. When you have to spend energy navigating the room before you can safely offer a view, the organisation is already bleeding brainpower it can't afford to lose, and probably doesn't even know it.

I've heard interruption defended as efficiency more times than I can count. I think it's usually a story leaders tell themselves when waiting feels less comfortable than acting, or when the pressure to move feels louder than the need to think clearly. When interrupting becomes habitual, you genuinely shouldn't be surprised when you start receiving sanitised updates, timid challenge, and the real conversation happening in lowered voices on the way back to the lifts.

(It's worth saying: In some communication cultures, overlapping speech signals enthusiasm rather than dismissal. That matters if you're leading or working across diverse teams, and it's worth understanding before reaching for a universal fix.)

People notice what happens to thinking in your presence. Then they adjust accordingly.

Next: Why asking people to be agile while placing their nervous systems under siege is a bit like standing on the hose and wondering why the water pressure is poor.

First published on LinkedIn.

If this describes something in your organisation, that’s a good place to start a conversation.